Making Code

And undir the arme the armynge poyntis muste be made of fyne twyne suche as men make stryn­gis for cross­bowes and they muste be trussid small and poyn­tid as poyntis. Also they muste be wexid with cordewen­eris coode. And than they woll neythir rec­che nor breke.”

“How a man schall be armyd at his ese when he schal fighte on foote” Hast­ings MS. [f.122b] c1450. See this page on chronique.com.

Code, or hand wax, is a sticky mix­ture of pitch and rosin, or rosin and beeswax, used to stick indi­vidual strands of linen together into a thread for sew­ing and to stick bristles on the tapered ends of the thread to act as lead­ers through the holes in the leather. From the quote above we know that it was also used on arm­ing points where it would both pro­tect them from mois­ture and make it almost impossible for them to become acci­dent­ally undone dur­ing com­bat. Its pro­tec­tion from mois­ture and rot is a key com­pon­ent of it’s role in shoe­mak­ing threads, which are exposed to mois­ture more than other gar­ments and which will rap­idly rot out unless protected.

For a full dis­cus­sion of the topic of medi­eval code, see Marc Carlson’s page on the stuff. I won’t go into it here because that’s a far more com­plete over­view of it than I could give. For mod­ern hand wax, there is an extens­ive dis­cus­sion, includ­ing recip­ies, on the Crispin Col­loquy, the web forum of the mod­ern day Hon­or­able Com­pany of Cord­wain­ers (incor­por­ated in Amer­ica but with mem­bers the world over), where many bespoke boot and shoe­makers dis­cuss their trade. Note that the first link is to the dis­cus­sion, the site uses frames so there’s no nav­ig­a­tion side­bar on the dis­cus­sion. You need to go to the main page for that, but the site is well worth exploring.

I will explain bristles and thread more fully in a sep­ar­ate post soon, I just happened to need to make some more code recently so I took pho­tos along the way.

The code I use is not a period recipie. It is what I think is mod­ernly called blond wax. Period wax likely used pine pitch and rosin rather than rosin and wax. This means it, and threads made with it, would have been black. I haven’t tried this yet because I haven’t found a source for pine pitch in less than indus­trial quantities.

It is well worth your time to read the links above before you start mak­ing this stuff. In par­tic­u­lar go back and read all the archives of the dis­cus­sion on the Crispin Col­loquy in order, there are some good hints in there on what makes a good wax.

I use a basic 2:1 mix­ture, by weight, of pine rosin and clean yel­low beeswax. This pro­duces a wax that works for me, at the tem­per­at­ures I work in, with the batch of rosin and wax I have at the moment. You will almost cer­tainly need to tune the mix­ture to suit your own envir­on­ment and ingredi­ents. I’m pretty sure the batch I made before was 1:1 rosin and wax, but I was using dif­fer­ent wax for that batch and it came out way too soft in that ratio with the wax I have now. You will most likely need to exper­i­ment to find the exact recipe that works for you.

As you exper­i­ment keep care­ful writ­ten track of the quant­it­ies and ratios of the ingredi­ents, and keep your fin­ished exper­i­mental wax in labelled bag­gies. If you do this you’ll be able to re-melt failed exper­i­mental tries and know what you’re start­ing with and what new ratios adding X amount of rosin or wax will res­ult in. It also means that when you find a recipe that works, you can repeat it when you need more or if you are work­ing with dif­fer­ent ingredi­ents you have a start­ing point that should pro­duce some­thing approx­im­ately right.

Before you use a new batch of wax on a shoe, build some seams in scrap pieces of leather and see how it works. This will save you build­ing a bad seam in a pro­ject you’re try­ing to finish.

The ambi­ent tem­per­at­ure you work at is import­ant. You need a harder wax in sum­mer and a slightly softer one in winter. If you live some­where with par­tic­u­larly hot sum­mers you may well find that you can’t work in sum­mer unless you have air con­di­tion­ing. Past a cer­tain tem­per­at­ure, the wax just won’t set enough to do it’s job. Bristles will pull off and stitches won’t lock. The only thing to do at that point is to stop work­ing until it’s cooler.

When the wax is at room tem­per­at­ure and hasn’t been handled it should be hard. I’ve found that if it is at all mal­le­able at this point then it is most likely too soft to reli­ably hold a bristle on the thread. Warmed in the hand it should become tacky but never goopy. It’s a little harder to tell when it’s too hard, but if you wax up a thread and it sheds ‘dandruff’ dur­ing sew­ing or when a thread that has been waxed and left to set sheds where it is flexed then it’s too brittle.

Wax is sup­posed to be sticky, it is not a lub­ric­ant like plain beeswax is. As well as hold­ing the bristle on the thread the wax melts slightly as it is dragged through a stitch and then sets again. The stick­i­ness locks the stitches together in the stitch hole and con­trib­utes a sig­ni­fic­ant amount of strength to the seam. I have cut the external parts of stitches off and still had to use pli­ers to pull the pieces of leather apart because they were held together with little pegs of waxed thread. This also stops the stitch you have just made from becom­ing loose when you release the ten­sion on the thread. A good test of a wax is if you pull both threads part way through a stitch and leave them to sit for 20 seconds it should take a good hard yank to get them mov­ing again after the wax has set them together.

Any­way, on to the mak­ing. This pro­cess involved muck­ing about with very hot melted stuff that will stick to you like nap­alm and cause nasty burns. Don’t spill it on your­self m’kay?

ingredients

Start with your ingredi­ents. Rosin can be found in vari­ous places but it can take a bit of hunt­ing to find a good sup­ply. That stuff came from an antiques res­tor­a­tion sup­ply place in Bris­bane (thanks Dave!) called Goods and Chat­tels. Mis­tress M found a sup­ply in NZ from a surf wax com­pany of all places. Smal­ler quant­it­ies can be found at arts sup­ply stores but expect to pay about 10x the price per gram there as you would buy­ing it else­where [EDIT: rosin can be bought by the kilo quite cheaply in New Zea­l­and from main­land paints. Good ser­vice, cheap ship­ping, and the rosin is good qual­ity. They also sell proper spirit tur­pen­tine]. Beeswax you get from apiarists.

crushedrosin

Crushed Rosin. It pays to hold your hand over the top of the mor­tar and have some news­pa­per spread out as chips of rosin tend to go fly­ing when you’re break­ing up the big­ger lumps.

Before you start melt­ing any­thing get a bucket and fill it mostly full of luke­warm water. You’ll need this later, even if you don’t set your­self on fire.

mahbukkit2

Weigh out your ingredi­ents. Be reas­on­ably accur­ate with this and remem­ber to zero your scales after you’ve put your con­tainer on before you fill it with the mater­ial. Yes, I’ve made that mistake.

weighingwax

I won­der how many points™ 70g of beeswax is? I ended up using 60g of wax and 60g of rosin in this round, and it was way too soft so I had to go back and redo it. The other prob­lem is that 120g of ingredi­ents is about twice as much as it’s easy to taffy-pull (see below) so if you’re just mak­ing it for your­self, do 60g total. That’ll make a lump big enough for sev­eral pairs of shoes. If you need to do a big batch pour a part of it at a time when the time comes.

biggercan

I use a big tin can to melt stuff in. I’ve pinched a spout into this one. If you use a sauce­pan be pre­pared to never use it for any­thing else because you won’t get the wax residue off the inside. If you do use a tin can, make sure it doesn’t have a plastic coat­ing on the inside, or scrub it off if it does, oth­er­wise you’ll get melted flakes of plastic in your wax, and that’s not good eats.

rosinallmelted

Start by melt­ing the rosin. I’m hold­ing the tin can in a pot of boil­ing water with pot holder used on camp­ing pots. You can do this over dir­ect heat, but you need to be care­ful. Both ingredi­ents are some­what volat­ile when heated and highly flam­mable. I did the ini­tial melt of the rosin dir­ectly over the ele­ment on low because the boil­ing water wasn’t quite hot enough to get it really liquid but once it was melted I went back to the double boiler arrange­ment. An actual double boiler or a mini crock pot would be ideal for this.

beeswaxadded

Once the rosin is all melted, add the beeswax. Rosin has a higher melt­ing point that beeswax so it’s easier to melt the wax into the rosin than to try melt­ing the rosin into the wax.

allmelted

When everything is melted together prop­erly it should be a clear amber color and you should be able to see the bot­tom of the tin. Ignore the white blobs in this, the bot­tom of the tin was plastic coated…

pouringwax

Once you have melted everything together, pour it into the bucket of luke­warm water. I’ve found that if the water is too cold, like cold tap water in winter, you’ll get hard bits form­ing too quickly.

pullingwaxunderwater

Keep­ing your hands under water grab the lump, squish it together and pull it apart. You need to do this under water because the core of the lump will still be liquid and very, very hot. Repeat until there isn’t any more sear­ingly hot liquid bits then pull it out of the water.

A note about the fol­low­ing sequence of pic­tures; I’m doing this with about twice as much wax as I should be and the wax didn’t come out very well because of that. A lump much big­ger than a golf ball is too hard to manip­u­late thor­oughly. You need to be able to squish the wax around in your hand to keep it soft while you go through this process.

Grab your lump of still-soft wax…

taffypull5

and pull…

taffypull2

smoosh it back together…

taffypull4

and repeat

taffypull3

This pro­cess is called “taffy-pulling”, which appar­ently makes sense if you’re famil­iar with the man­u­fac­ture of tra­di­tional Amer­ican con­fec­tion­ery. It is crit­ical to the final product. A lot of the mix­ing of ingredi­ents hap­pens here and without this step the wax will have strata of wax and rosin that aren’t fully com­bined. When you’re done with this the whole ball should be a uni­form pale yel­low. The wax will take quite a long time to fully cool. Leave it overnight before you use it.

ballsofwax

The balls of wax res­ult­ing from this exer­cise. Note marbled color. This wax isn’t fully com­bined because I was work­ing with too much when I taffy-pulled it. I have since re melted one of these balls and added more rosin and it came out much bet­ter the second time around. I don’t have pic­tures of that though, sorry.

ballinbag

You can store sur­plus wax in air­tight bag­gies. That way it won’t stick to any­thing if it acci­dent­ally gets a bit warm. I’ve heard people say you should store it in water to stop it dry­ing out. I’m not sure how neces­sary that is but I have found that it is more usable 24 hours or so after mak­ing than it is right after it has cooled.

Enjoy. Feel free to ask ques­tions if that didn’t make sense and please share your exper­i­ences mak­ing the stuff in the comments.

12 Comments

12 Responses

  1. Ant Queen says:

    Hi Wil­liam, Art here :) I can’t believe I haven’t found your blog before.

    Great detailed instruc­tions and pho­tos to boot! I am def­in­itely giv­ing this a go when I fin­ish studying.

    In the mean­time, I’m head­ing off to the UK next week. We’ll be based in York (thus check­ing out all things Jor­vik), then head­ing briefly up north to the Vin­dolanda and Roman Army museum up near Hadrian’s wall, then a few days in Lon­don to do V&A;, Museum of Lon­don and whatever else we can fit in.

    Any sug­ges­tions of places to go for extant shoe finds would be wel­come. We’re tak­ing many memory cards for the cam­era, plus tape meas­ures and set squares to get scale for the pics.

  2. Not An Elf says:

    Hi Wil­liam,
    We tried the code mak­ing at an event here in Tas­mania in Septem­ber 2007. It was reas­on­ably warm (no less than 3 degrees at any point) and we tried the code in the early afternoon.

    We used an old home brew syrup can as our boiler.

    We were pretty rough with our meas­ur­ments, but it was pretty close to 2:1 and we melted down the the rosin and then threw in the wax. The whole mass was bub­bling away and we got ourselves a 10L bucket of warm water.

    While pour­ing the mix into the water, we observed that the rosin was pre­cip­it­at­ing straight out of the mix and we had a totally non-homogenous mix.

    We took it all out dried it off a bit and rehae­ated it and tried again. Same res­ult. A large ball of wax with rosin crys­tals in it, and a pile of crys­tals in the bucket.

    The next time we filled the (now metal) bucket with straight hot water. We got the toughest guy we knew (took a hi-lift jack to the face in the solomons, got microsur­gery and wanted to go straight back to work), and had him pretty much catch the mix as it went into the bucket. Through a lot of work­ing he was able to keep it homo­gen­ous, and even the bits that we stuck to his skin were OK.

    My guess is that the prob­lem was the rate of cool­ing for that par­tic­u­lar batch of rosin. Thoughts?

  3. Teffania says:

    I’m try­ing to chase rosin before easter, and I think I might be mad for the dead­line. But any­way, I was won­der­ing how pine tar (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pine_tar) which seems to be more avail­able (as stock­holm tar) relates to rosin and pine pitch — is it a com­pletely dif­fer­ent product to these two?

  4. @Not an Elf

    I haven’t been able to repro­duce this prob­lem with the rosin pre­cip­it­at­ing out to the degree that you describe.

    I’ve man­aged to get a batch with a few crunchy bits in but noth­ing that didn’t dis­s­apear with the taffy-pulling phase, so I’m not really sure what to suggest.

    I can’t think of any­thing other than what you sug­gest that it is some­thing to do with your batch of rosin, sorry.

    I’m going to be get­ting some dif­fer­ent rosin soon because my cur­rent sup­ply is run­ning out and if I have the prob­lems you describe I’ll let you know.

  5. @teffania:

    Pine tar and rosin are very dif­fer­ent. I strongly advise against using pine tar/stockholm tar unless you want to make a really huge smelly mess, annoy any­one you cohabit with, and get bit lumps of sticky black stuff in the fur of any anim­als you cohabit with.

    Yes, I’m speak­ing from experience :-)

    Pine rosin is the stuff in the mor­tar on the left in the first pic­ture of the post. It is hard and pale golden brown to yel­low­ish in color.

    Pine tar/stockholm tar is a black smoky-smelling liquid goo.

    They both come from pine trees, but the rosin is the res­ult of dis­til­la­tion of sap whereas the tar is the res­ult of destruct­ive dis­til­la­tion of the actual wood (the root stock for the good stuff). If you dis­till stock­holm tar down fur­ther you get pitch, which is what is men­tioned in the earli­est recipie for code that I know of in the The Art and Mys­tery of a Cord­wainer, by John F. Rees, Lon­don, 1813.

    I have some Gugolz optical lap­ping pitch that I have tried with some suc­cess soften­ing with stock­holm tar but all of my attempts to com­bine it with rosin to make a usable code have failed, spec­tac­u­larly messily for the last attempt.

    What I need to do is sci­en­tific­ally work out the ratio of pitch/tar to make a use­fully soft pitch and then work out the ratio of soft pitch/rosin to make a use­ful code.

    Be assured that once I do I will post the recipe here, but from my exper­i­ments so far it will be a long, smelly and extremely messy pro­cess that may not be worth repeat­ing given the rel­at­ive ease of mak­ing code out of beeswax and rosin.

  6. Teffania says:

    Thanks for the quick answer. I’d love to hear about the exper­i­ments with pitch that don’t work even. Now back to the great quest for rosin in stock at an afford­able price.

  7. Teffania says:

    Rosin found. Ballarina’s Resin. $8.50 AU/500g. Might not be the best value, but it’s a lot cheaper than violinist’s rosin.

    Comes con­veni­ently powdered, but they left a few chunks in just so I can be sure it’s not been altered, and I can check out the colour.

    So far it hasn’t made a nice code though — it won’t melt or stay liquid over a double boiler. A 2:1 batch of rosin to beeswax behaved like pure rosin. A 1:1 ratio (for sumer use) of rosin to “pure beeswax candle” is very hot to handle, but cools within about a minute, and is only easy to taffy pull while almost too hot to handle and still under­wa­ter. It quickly gets too stiff and snaps like rock sugar. I think I see a few rosin crys­tals crys­tal­ising out too. The col­our is a dark yellow.

    I’ll let it cool overnight (although it seems fairly cool and stiff within 10 minutes), and try a batch with more beeswax, and hope that is the prob­lem, not the quality/variety of wax or the rosin.

    Thanks for your great guide — I wouldn’t have got­ten this far without it, or been able to be sure that my batches were get­ting closer, but not right yet.

  8. Hi Tef­fania,

    That’s not too bad a price for rosin com­pared to what I’ve seen some people pay.

    Rosin often won’t melt copm­letely over a double boiler. I had to melt mine over dir­ect heat, just be care­ful not to bring it to a hard boil.

    It is much easier to melt the rosin com­pletely first and once it is nice and liquid add the beeswax. Rosin has the higher melt­ing point so try­ing to melt it into the beeswax means you have to come dan­ger­ously close to burn­ing the beeswax to get it hot enough to melt and integ­rate the rosin.

    Don’t lose heart, it took me quite a few tries to get a good batch. Keep try­ing, but be sure to write down the exact details of everything you do, what ratios of ingredi­ents etc you use so you can repeat the res­ults next time.

    Have fun.

  9. I have just fin­ished my first batch of code, thanks to the recipe given in this art­icle.
    Everything went really well exept for the melt­ing of the rosin.
    The tem­per­at­ure in the double boiler was too low.
    I just put the wax and the rosin in the same con­tainer and put it in the oven at 160 degrees celsius for about 15 minutes. That worked really well.

    Thanks for the instruc­tions! Im’ really look­ing for­ward to try work­ing with this stuff :-)

  10. Lorenzo says:

    Another pos­sible source for rosin…

    it’s com­monly used by rodeo folks. Bull and bronco riders apply it to their gloves and rope for a bet­ter grip.

    In the US:
    I found mine at this place:
    http://www.usrodeosupply.com

    $10 for a 1lb bag. Since then, I’ve seen it a bit cheaper at other places.

  11. Thanks Larry, the more sources the better.

  12. Simone says:

    Hi Al, just a note to let you know that I made a batch this morn­ing at 2:1 and it’s look­ing pretty good. I bought a bunch of bristles from Fran­cis and so if I can get over my fear of wood­work to make lasts I am almost ready to start mak­ing some shoes again. With I bit of luck I’ll have some to show you at Can­ter­bury Faire next year, if you can make it. cheers Min

Leave a Reply

 

Using Gravatars in the comments - get your own and be recognized!

XHTML: These are some of the tags you can use: <a href=""> <b> <blockquote> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>